Unraid vs synology reddit. The data pool setup alone would make me use unraid.

Unraid vs synology reddit And if you ever did need it scale uses the kvm virtualization engine vs the hive virtualization engine for FreeBSD. I have a separate machine that runs Plex. Appreciate any guidance anyone has for coding illiterate to get either of these running on a synology NAS. I've never been happier with my home server. They want to compare transcoding to a different client when the DS920+ is the server vs. The Synology is a great nas so no complaints. You don't NEED Windows for any of that. I saw too many people throwing that term around with Unraid in threads the last few days (not saying you did). I can buy a refurbed corporate PC with a lot more muscle than a Synology for less than half the price ($150 vs $400 for a DS220+) but that isn't as "set and forget" as a Synology unit. This issue currently focuses me on Unraid, but the lack of proper backup solutions (snapshots) and some strange addons that seem to be necessary (like „fix common problems) don’t feel like a proper solution for the next, maybe 10 years. The disadvantages are limited functionality and inability to do even the simplest things which are "not typical", "closed" OS which is going to get updates for a limited amount of time, becoming unsafe to use after that and in the case of what you've chosen very I have had a synology nas for quite a few years and have now switched to a self made home server running unraid. I would also like to use MakeMKV and MKVToolNix on the server. 2K drives? I am a bit spooked by the reviews stating that the ADM interface compared to DSM and the mobile apps are unpolished and outdated compared to the Synology siblings. (dual xeon, 64gig of ram, dual platinum psu and hw raid with cache and most important idrac management) Synology or 2. to be able to use Unraid. com with This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. No contest. Want to add storage? Just add hard drives. Trying to stay clear of QNAP but then trying to force you to use their own branded hard drives be careful. Synology's C2 Hybrid Cloud product also just works great out of the box and the HyperBackup product for servers and desktops is again worth like $1,000 a year. Since my unraid server is overpowered with a good processor and a p2200 for hardware acceleration on Plex, jellyfin and emby, I will need the Synology box to just be a storage server. For some reason, I thought that ECC RAM is a given for NAS brands like Synology. so if there security flaw relating to plex, your system likely will get compromised (ie ransomware). Since you used the command line synology is treating them the same as ones made in the GUI. My understanding is that hive has historically been quirky. You still have to have a understanding of what you're doing, certainly above the average computer user. I thought I was able to sync (or perhaps back up from Synology) one folder in Synology with Unraid. r/LinusTechTips. SMB is set up on synology and firewall is also allowed. While Unraid offers a simpler and easier-to-set-up solution with built-in Docker and NAS features, I found that virtualizing TrueNAS on a Proxmox cluster and passing through my actual drives worked better for my needs. r/Proxmox. Ease of use with web dashboard i taught pc novices how to use it or i hide from them and they just copy whatever to share on another family windows pcs. It'll have an internal 1TB SSD, but my main movie storage and docker configs (basically all persistent data) would ideally be on the Synology and mounted via NFS or something like that. If you like the Synology OS but don't have the Synology Hardware, then run DIY hardware and Xpenology OS If you don't want Synology OS, but have the Synology Hardware, run DIY hardware with unraid. It is maddening and something I just need to sort, decide and move on. Build an unRaid System that Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. there isn't really any harm in running it in Host mode. same bus speed as well. SHR is Synology's own RAID. Synology in my case was a quick worry-free setup that satisfied all my needs with the option to expand in the future. Having an unraid box to combine I got this at the price of a new qts hero nas or a synology nas with ecc ram support. I wanted a Synology for better storage options + Buy a better server, but still silent and low power. Linus Tech Tips - This Meaning I'd either have to have new drives and transfer wanted data from unraid to Synology. My unRAID box is more like 90%. But syncthing didn't actually sync the entire Synology NAS. My downtime over a year is less than a day. Very easy. 2ghz chip at 100% is doing the same performance or a dual core 1ghz can do over 120MB on a set of 5400's on the same network switch to the same clients with the same files. The hardware is really expensive for what it is. You can have many pools, but if you ever built a massive array of disks, you're boned if you needed a large pool. And got much much more ram and performance. Color me old school, but after upgrading all my synology's to 7. eSATA is direct communication to target device while USB 3 there is a USB to SATA bridge in between, View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. 5TB whilst have 2 parity disks as well as regular BTRFS scrubbing to ensure no silent loss of data due to bad sectors AND it'll by default email you Unraid is more difficult (I’m a newb in this area) Moreover, I’m not sure which home sec app would be best and which cams should I buy. SHR seems like a similar setup to Unraid, since I have different sized hard drives (3TB, 3TB, 2TB, 2TB, 500GB, and separately 12TB). However in my experience they do just work which is nice as i need this thing to not break midway and not break halfway. I've recently been reading about the Synology and their AI photo moments software which would allow me to easily search my 15+ So i currently have a synology 8 bay NAS which i actually quite like but unfortunately i'm starting to run out of space. It's got nowhere near the muscle of newer models, and rebuilding 8 drives takes forever (especially since I fucked up and made two volumes on 1 storage pool when I'd wanted a second storage pool), but it Just Works(TM). TrueNAS Scale is based on linux, and I guess easier, We're now read-only indefinitely due to Reddit Incorporated's poor management and decisions related to third party platforms and content management. If price is a I came across a free DS1817 with 40tb of disks in it and I want to add it to my unraid setup to expand my storage. I have a Synology DS1513+ running since 10 years without much trouble so far connected to a UPS. Except for the fiasco with all the 2022 models wanting you to use their own hard drives (HUGE) ripoff they are great. Just set up a sftp Docker container on Unraid, install either Vorta (Linux or MacOS) or Pika (Linux) on your client, enter the server credentials, set up your folders, rules and schedules in the UI, and that's it. Other options are Unraid (plus recommended plugins) or OMV+SnapRaid+Portainer+UnifedFS. Members Online. 1 volume on each giving a total of 32 TB. Synology alone has Drive (which competes with $50,000/year enterprise applications) and officially supported Dropbox/OneDrive etc integration. The CPU performance difference between the two is pretty significant, with the RS822+ having 2-4x times as much cache and about a 30% overall performance increase. unRAID runs between 68w and 80w Get the Reddit app Scan this Please, help me choose between synology, truenas, unraid builds for plex. Move to something like a Synology because why not. I've owned both Qnap and Synology as well as plethora of old relic enterprise equipment. Plex is also a Synology package, very easy to install. Do consider a cold spare to have around and maybe rotate into service occasionally though. - Buy a synology NAS, set it to SH2, filled with the drives & sell the old i7 computer- Set up FreeNas or unRAID on my old i7 full of the 12 drives According to Synology's website their SH2 protocol would retain around 18. A community to discuss Synology NAS and networking devices Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home I am more comfortable with Windows and stuck with Drivepool for quite a while as well, especially coming from Windows Home Server back in early 2010's. It also consumes a lot more power. Now my question is, since I have seen alot running UnRaid. It's user-friendly and you don't have to worry much about maintenance. My oldest gear is a 10 year old Synology (it's just a back up target now) - I had drives fail but the data stayed available thanks to raid - depending on your amount of data and raid it takes time to rebuild but this happens in the background and one can still access data at reduced performance. 5G and above, but unRAID can work with Cache, so you mitigate completely the difference and add a lot more performance than a standard raid, still you need a local connection better than 1G to notice difference. Can play massive h264 files just file on an old celeron, but even a small h265 is basically a slideshow. Smaller form factor is about the only advantage Synology has, but micro-itx builds can get reasonably close. com with Go to unRAID r/unRAID. Since my Synology DS216play is about to go on its knees, I‘ve decided to build my own NAS and move to unraid. What Unraid is doing is try to do build a sustainable business model. I am trying to decide between using a Synology NAS or building my own server using TrueNAS or Unraid. Unless you also use UPnP in plex then you also wouldn't have to worry that they are forwarded on your router automatically and accessible from outside. 5GbE adapter to connect to the Synology, and mounted the network storage using auto mount SMB Shares. Yay I finally maxed out my Unraid mobo today: max ram capacity, You could throw together some cheaper parts or even repurpose used hardware and build a completely serviceable NAS at a fraction of the price, or ball out with optane metadata, SSD cache/slog, maximum ram, dual head HDDs, quadro GPU, and build something that would smoke a Synology in benchmarks, but it’s unlikely these stats would make a massive difference in coming from DS420j then upgrading to DS923+, having 1GB ram vs 4GB, that difference could be felt. To make things easier I'm considering using Unraid on a Lenovo Tiny. (It really depends on your end goals. Or check it out in the app stores I started using HA was for about 2 years with a vm on synology. Don't use your Synology for anything but storing files and like dns/dhcp if you really want to. Can't be said enough raid is not a backup. That is what leads to enshittification. I can not speak about Synology / QNAP, but I've had an unRAID system for over 4 years now, and it's been very solid. UPDATE – The UniFi UNAS Pro NAS is now available and can be found HERE. TrueNAS is great if you want to tinker and roll out your own powerful hardware. My unraid server runs as virtuell machine in my VMware cluster. Then I use unraid on Lenovo mini pc to just run apps I want. I didn't have any real issues setting up all the stuff I I've had an 4 bay asustor for over a year now. Both appear to use a Parity drive and allow you to add as many other disks in any size (given they are smaller than the Parity drive) to expand your storage array. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. , etc. I like the fact that I was able to build a PC from commodity hardware, configure it how I want it, and then use unRAID for a fault-tolerant storage space. I've been a Synology user since Black Friday last year when I picked up the DS1621+. trueNAS is based on zfs raidsets which doesn’t allow you to add drives to the existing pool. " Ultimately, I chose Synology over Unraid because I sought something that functions seamlessly and offers an interface simple enough for my wife to navigate, should I meet an untimely demise. Would Unraid be a good option in my situation, or would something like Ubuntu be better? Synology to Unraid. Unraid is imo, hands down the best home server OS on the market by a very large margin. is just different. unRAID wasn't really happy about having no redundancy, but I just used nightly snapshots to backup the NVME/unRAID data to the Synology. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. You want something with built in integrity checks too, and you don't want to be guessing if errors are parity versus data. Or check it out in the app stores I do have a separate Synology NAS that has 4 x 12tb, this led me down the thought train that xpenology might be an option I then looked at truenas, then at unraid This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, unRAID 7. Raw non-VPN speed was about 266 Mbps (essentially my ISP account speed, so the Synology was capable of running at my full speed). With Operating systems like Unraid and FreeNAS/TrueNAS maintaining the Server got very easy and convenient. Originally designed for computer architecture research at Berkeley, RISC-V is now used in everything from $0. I'm particularly interested in learning more about the software side of both brands because this is being so rarely mentioned. Pure RAID is much more limiting, and essentially requires that all of the drives are the same size. Pre-Built NAS systems usually rely on some package manager that is rarely updated (plex for example is probably 2 years old the last time I saw a post about this), in regards to plex you would need to manually update it. " I haven't used Unraid but I believe the license cost ($59-129) is significantly less than the cost of buying into the Synology ecosystem. I wondered the same, then I just made a Synology VM on my Proxmox server and it’s been great. I'm starting to plan what The fact that people still consider qnap vs synology is astounding to me, I would’ve thought forums would be riddled with anti-qnap posts. identical drives in both the synology and the unraid. So you get to make a choice, cost of extra drive vs (unlikely) risk of losing extra drive during rebuild. Synology - The easiest way to set up a reliable Plex server. Works flawlessly, and backblaze backup works exactly the same as my old synology. And I'm really worried people will "soon" get stuck, once it's officially in unraid. I run a scale setup I built and a synology 1821+. Anybody have experience with running VMs and Dockers in XPEnology? I'm wondering how developed that ecosystem is compared to unRAID. A Synology or Qnap NAS allows you to add drives to their volumes but have inferior specs compared to your setup. I have a Synology DS218+ and I enjoy it a lot. 2 years ago I kicked a dual 2660v4 Xeon machine to the curb, moved to Unraid and a modern build. Pros learn a lot Plex took 50 million in a round and now has to be pedal to the metal to increase return to investors at all costs. The data pool setup alone would make me use unraid. Synology will be probably a safer bet for your case since you get a lot of functionality out of the box - Synology Photos / Moments and Drive are better from my POV than any other open-source solution on the market. plex package have direct access to your system vs docker is isolated from your main system. But I still use Drivepool as a plain file backup of my Synology NAS. It's docker ui is very good. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. It would also just be a few seconds difference. Hardware Hello, I am considering using a Plex server for storing and streaming movies, TV shows, photos, and documents. Based on your wishes I’d say go with unraid. Come and join us today! Members Online. That's why I went 10th gen. I like how Synology is dummy proof I wouldn't call Synology dummy proof. TrueNAS vs Synology vs Qnap The YouTube user SpaceRex (u/spacerex1776 on Reddit) posted this video a couple of days ago comparing TrueNAS with you know how to use the internet, and find reddit), I would recommend Certainly the BSD version of TrueNAS isn't very friendly with it's Jails and the likes, compared to Docker on unRAID/Synology. Or check it out in the app stores choosing the HDD's for ds423+ WD red plus vs synology HAT3300 6TB NAS hardware but thought I'd give y'all an update on my upgraded 90TB Unraid Server Buy a Synology or build an Unraid box Use it via Samba/SMB only - Synology's apps aren't worth the time IMO Ensure no direct remote access is possible (no port forwarding!), and all user accounts are secured with limited permissions to prevent against attacks Then I used a USB 3. Reply reply A reddit dedicated to the profession of Computer System Administration. docker container tends to get new updates vs package. Whilst most alot of users tend to think about only choosing between turnkey NAS+Software solutions from Synology/QNAP/etc OR going DiY on the hardware with Open Source software installed (such as TrueNAS), UnRAID is part of the growing trend of choosing ‘something in between’ and allows users to turn almost anything into a server very easily. If you’ve not heard of the latter two, however, nobody could blame you. But yes for uptime sake I personally want redundancy. If you want a balance between ease of use and flexibility: UnRAID could be a great middle ground Ran into this the hard way myself. Synology DS220+, DS923+, or Unraid for Plex Server (4k Transcoding)? our old Buffalo NAS was used only as a local device with no connection to internet, but I've been reading about all the wonderful capabilities of Synology NASes and can't deny i feel very interested in trying things like: backing up on GDrive (using the subscription we already use with our phones), torrent downloading and dockers (something I've learned about just this past week). Up until now I've used Hyper-V VMs to house my Linux machines and docker containers. Well unraid and TNS are really not good mini pc options. But Hardware wise? Whoa. there also seems to be a lot more 'other things' that Synology can do that the Drobo can't, so there's that Build a Unraid machine Something else? My use case is primarily NAS storage; Plex files, work backups, etc. 14 votes, 33 comments. the Shield as a server. It's a rare use case where the minor performance differences and universal compatibility differences between SHR and RAID would necessitate choosing RAID, and giving up the flexibility of SHR. A fast NIC is important here, or complicated multiple paths. I will keep the Synology NAS to store my media files. Unless things have changed, UnRaid can't do anything beyond a RAID 6, so your pool can get as large as 30 drives (another limitation), but you are still limited to a parity of 2 drives. So i currently have a synology 8 bay NAS which i actually quite like but unfortunately i'm starting to run out of space. And yeah, it is the way I love it. RAID5 with 10K and 7. Depends your OS. $200 for the Synology one. I'd either go all the way to trueNAS or Windows Server or go the easy route with Synology. Increase VM after doing a bunch of research to match my needs (Run Home Assistant, Plex, VM, Remote Drives), it appears that a Synology NAS is what I need. The difference between the two configurations is what happens if you get unlucky and lose another drive during this rebuild: In SHR/RAID-5 setup, you lose data. Only difference between my asustor and my old synology was I saved a bundle of cash with asustor. Build an unRaid System that cannot be physically accessed for 5 r/Proxmox. Synology is recommended by many and Terramaster is quite cheaper compared to Synology. Unraid will of course have a learning curve, no different than learning QTS on Qnap or DSM on Synology. That easy. I've had one for 4 years with near 100% uptime. I would do this and test it out before investing on a Synology, but you don’t even need an actual Synology NAS. My personal suggestion is buy or build a nas. I'm leaning on Unraid, to make adding/swapping hard disks easier in the future for upgrading, and I like the UI a bit better. delivering unparalleled data protection and privacy vs. Again, you're not wrong but I think there is a middle ground between "just buy a Synology" and "build everything from FreeBSD on CLI, GUIs are for the weak. Software wise, sure, there was an improvement. I initially used Unraid for my home lab, but around 8 months ago, I switched to Proxmox, despite running about 20 Docker containers. the N305. And having the nvme cache drives for Plex and downloads makes a huge difference compared to the Synology. A little. A reddit dedicated to the profession of Computer System Administration. Have a new (to me) 16bay100TB SuperMicro dual Xeon E5-2695 v2, Quadro P4000, 198GB ECC Ram, 10Gb NIC server just waiting for a If I can’t use USB with Unraid, I would need to buy a NAS case, drive bays, PSU, etc. I tried unRaid, and I liked it about the Synology, QNAP, etc. So, when you say NAS (rather than backup which you've equated to my unRAID), do you mean a Synology device? If so, are you inferring the Synology device would alleviate What Is Unraid? What Is Synology NAS? Unraid VS Synology; Back Up Your Data; Wrapping It Up; In the Reddit homelab, one user mentioned that some disaster happens on his hard drive and he hope to choose between Synology is quite popular, but so is TrueNAS and Unraid. Unraid- very easy to use. If you use 3-2-1 backup strategy, you should be fine. as for zfs vs unraid, i personally use both but my media goes on unraid because it's more cost effective. A comparably priced unRAID build is going to run circles around it spec-wise, and be vastly more flexible overall. It's basically a nice gui for open-zfs and backups. I’m almost out of space on the synology and it’s so much easier to stick a drive in the unraid server. As far as i have read so far, you need to run unraid from a usb drive. The learning curve to set everything up wasn’t too bad and I managed to find all the info I need on either Reddit, YouTube, or the Unraid Proxmox is more powerful when it comes to more advanced vm features, like snapshots, clustering, etc. com with What, exactly- if any- are the benefits of switching your drives from 512e to 4Kn? I've spent the last few hours perusing the internet, the majority of the 42 r/synology posts that contain "4Kn" and a number of the dozen posts that contain "4k" and "Sector" without finding an answer. UnRaid is not free either. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at https://discourse. SynologyPros quick setup (time) stable Cons you have to spend $ performance if you run heavy apps TrueNAS. I'm dealing with kind of a headache here. Specifically Truenas does not purposefully and maliciously neuter their software to try to force you to buy unnecessarily expensive nonsense from them. But unraid and zfs, if when running on unraid, are the opposite, as you explain. I mean an 8 bay NAS with minimal specs is 1k+. Synology is typically very underspec'd for their price point, and upgrades like RAM or cache have very high markup. Wether doing something with synology or building a machine and using either FreeBSD or Unraid. Especially not scale since zfs devours ram. In SHR6/RAID-6 setup, you are good, unless you lose one more drive. unraid > synology. r/unRAID. (3) What’s your experience? Synology: plug&play low maintenance reliable no home sec and cams compatibility risks Synology cams are expensive no upgrade options Pull out an drive and store for repair, setup in raid 6 as it will be upgradeable to raid F1 or to run inside xs-class Nas , from DSM 7 raid management it's as flexible for raid 56 as for shr1/2, DSM 7 allows live repair rebuild plugging an drive into an empty slot when s warning suggest some drive may die, it's much more quicker and safe than waiting for Post Morten rebuild. It's pretty easy if you're a MacOS or Linux user. Synology uses like 35w. Or check it out in the app stores Not sure if the delta is the Synology USB driver or the enclosure firmware. Synology vs Unraid vs FreeBSD upvotes · comments. . If you decide to go for unRAID, do yourself a favor and watch a few of Spaceinvader One's videos about planning your shares on youtube. com with Generally unRAID is a bit slower in writing, but not slower than a 1G local connection, so you can feel the difference from a Raid5 configuration only if you have 2. For immediate help and problem RISC-V (pronounced "risk-five") is a license-free, modular, extensible computer instruction set architecture (ISA). Those may all be worked out by now. No weak spots :) On the ebay note I just bought 2x15 bay enclosures for under 200 last week. I had very good results running vms. As I explained, It makes a few things easier with Plex in particular. On the synology side I was looking at the 1823xs+ witn either IronWolf Pros or Exos drives (need to do research on what is quieter). Since both have BTRFS, you can choose whichever of the two (DS423+ or DS923+) I'm not sure how big of a factor ECC vs Non-ECC memory is. Usual stuff. If you never want anything more than a Synology NAS go for it! They must be popular for a reason) Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I think deciding between SHR2 and raid6 is basically as simple as deciding when you want your extra space to show up when you increase drive sizes. It's super good at caring about your data compared to unraid which is more aimed towards ease of use and doing a lot of things. If you want to run some VMs and Plex, get a box to do that, have them point at the Synology storage I've had limited experience with UnRAID myself, but it seems pretty simple and straight forward and just works. Topology planned is Synology > Unraid > Client. Synology Hardware. 22 votes, 18 comments. I get to keep running all my VMs and containers but also get to use Synology, their CCTV system is amazing. practicalzfs. Unraid runs from a USB stick so you don't need to dedicate a sata port to the OS drive. ). Everything else you want can be done with Docker (also Synology package). centralized cloud object storage alternatives. 10 CH32V003 microcontroller chips to the pan-European supercomputing initiative, with 64 core 2 GHz workstations in between. The server would be connected to the NAS through SMB network share. Cause the main selling point (imo) of unraid is the easy expanding with different size disks, while a lot of people try to push zfs (again, many advantages, I know). 133K subscribers in the synology community. For I have a Synology DiskStation DS418j. Is there a significant price difference? Otherwise synology all the way, or if u don’t need The first would be to buy a Synology NAS, perhaps a DS220+ or a similar 4-bay, but it is really expensive compared to building my own server. Less customizable compared to the other two options. Currently I have 12 data drives (and 1 parity, 1 cache), so 15 drives total. Or find somewhere to store the data (GDrive) until I This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. But it's not very powerful, so to augment it, I've been working on an Unraid box for the last few months. tend to be under-powered (especially on the low end) for the price and you can almost always build a more powerful unRAID server for the same price. It's nothing like UnRAID. Synology due to the way that Synology devices must be purchased/used. I have a DS1821+ currently containing 8 x 8TB drives configured as 4 storage pools of SHR-1. There are lots of options that I’m looking into but I’m not sure I fully understand the SHR and UnRAID setups. I've been managing Synology devices for last 10-11 years and never had issues. If uptime is your primary factor, go Synology. Running a defrag (assuming we are talking about btrfs defrag) on a synology box could be a surefire way to waste a lot of drive space if snapshots are enabled, or Synology Drive has versioning turned on, or docker is installed - basically in any scenario where btrfs snapshots are present. I'm running Just moved from Synology to Unraid and let me tell you Then you can always virtualize truenas inside of unraid to learn / test it out. currently, I‘m struggling to make a decision between the Intel Core N100 vs. If you have a good deal on a Synology box, just the Synology OS. I coincidentally did some testing on VPN speed yesterday. . I just want Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. The advantage of synology is - it is simple appliance which will "just work" as long as you needs fit typical configuration. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Unraid and truenas are both amazing. If you’d like to use a Synology NAS, your options are extremely limited as you can only use DSM (Synology’s To add to what u/q1ung said, you can use things like Storage Spaces inside windows which can provide you that redundancy that you get with Unraid. I've recently been doing some research on getting myself a NAS setup and came across Terramaster and Synology as two potential choices. Running TrueNAS, Unraid, or Ubuntu Server from used enterprise hardware would be way cheaper and more powerful but not as convenient. Does anyone have any recommendations for tools or docker containers that Hardware Differences: Unraid vs. Other possible factors: OMV is free but unraid has a cost $60 usd. Has anyone come across any guides/videos to get Notifiarr or Recyclarr running on a Synology NAS? Ibracorp has a video but it's geared to Unraid and I attempted to Native install via the Notifiarr wiki but I get errors that it fails to start in the logs. The only downsides to unraid- The cache isn't based on mru or lru. I also like the idea of having extra bays for future use/playing around with. RAID10 is a combination of RAID 1 and Raid 0. We are a community that My unraid setup is simply to backup my synology. It's a bit like wearing a seatbelt or a rubber for that matter, it protects, even though issues might not always happen that often (relatively speaking, even though repercussions can be grave), however what Linus stated was also that without ECC we'd not even know that memory corruption even was the issue, unlike suffering from a crash or a STD of the first two protective methods As a matter of fact, I currently use both. So don't use raid5/shr + hotspare over raid6/shr2. I have been very pleased with it and happy I didn't bother building a FreeNAS box. However, to that end, has anyone moved to Unraid from Synology and would you go b ack. There is a significant difference when comparing Unraid vs. Pro's of Synology: - Very stable. I have my Synology as a backplane and OMV accesses the drives in the Synology over an NFS share using the remote mount plugin. I had that setup for a while along with a lot of the downloader apps in windows. Recommendations: If you prioritize ease of use and are willing to pay for it: Go for Synology. I'm running a Dell T5500 with 2x Xeon X5650, 72GB of RAM, and random older Radeons in it. For immediate help and problem solving, I signed up for the 30-day trial of Unraid, then tinkered with syncthing. Or check it out in the app stores Projects are docker compose. I dabbled with UnRAID, TrueNAS, OMV for a while, but in the end went with a Synology NAS. The other thing is the initial configuration of unRAID is a bit more fiddly than Synology - not that it is difficult or anything - the concept of caching, shares. From what I can tell a DIY build is cheaper and more expandable. I'm also concerned about future expandability on both the Synology and the Truenas/Unraid route. We’ll look at some differences below. Here is my truncated view: Use Case/Thoughts. The biggest difference is FreeBSD(Core) vs Linux(Scale) and since I’m a Linux guy I chose scale. TrueNAS in the 95% of my content is high-res photography in RAW and JPG. As others have said, different platforms and solutions have different strengths and weaknesses. I dont need VMs (maybe 1 max to mess around) and don't need storage management since I have the NAS. The data/parity setup is much simpler to get going on unraid, as compared to the mergerfs/snapraid setup on OMV. Personally I run OMV as just a dumb file server. (Also btrfs (which I use The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest . Synology vs UniFi NAS Comparison. you get more capacity per dollar spent, greater flexibility with expansion and it consumes less power because it's not striping my data across multiple drives. This allows front-end users to use OMV to get their files but gives me all the goodies like backups by using their Synology Cloud Sync. JBOD vs RAID 0 . the other ports as listed here are just for other parts of Plex like the DLNA server. I keep flip flopping between Synology, Unraid and my own spin of things. When I changed to unraid I therefor try the docker Version. I want to touch on briefly just on a single item in your text. I personally use unraid only as storage and with plex container as media station. I’ve heard the argument here on Reddit many times for Tailscale- not exposing NAS logins directly to the internet via port forwarding or using the tunnel vs the open port allows you to do 2 things to make it more secure: Number 1, you can set up Cloudflare Tailscale also easy on Synology as it is available at DSM app If you can buy everything at once, TrueNAS ZFS is an ideal solution. However, after perusing various opinions on Synology versus Unraid, the choice boiled down to "plug and play" versus "building and customization. 0. Or going for something easy like a Synology 1821+ which would sets me back about 1k € without drives. ftp support nfs support smb support, home grown drop box, download hunter. In the world of Network Attached Storage (NAS), Synology has been a dominant player for over two Hi All Someone here who have experience with Unraid as OS on a NAS from Qnap or Synology, This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. /r/StableDiffusion is back open after the protest of Reddit killing open API access, which will bankrupt app developers, but thought I'd give y'all an update on my upgraded 90TB Unraid Server Get the Reddit app Scan this I bought a brand new Intel 10gbe PCI card on eBay for $50 CDN vs. Synology is a great company with apple like quality and GUI. This is part of why I'm still rocking a ds1812+. If I need an visual Studio, I can add a docker from the Apps section. In terms of Synology - they are standard for small and mid-size companies. A community to discuss Synology NAS and networking devices but thought I'd give y'all an update on my upgraded 90TB Unraid Server r/sysadmin. A LOT of people don't like Unraid because of the data integrity challenges it has compared with other platforms. SELL the synology box and recoup some costs. My Synology DS420J has three 8TB disks, is configured as SHR1 (RAID5). How good is UnRaid? My original plan was to buy a Synology DS1515+ or 1815 and run esxi on my server. My planned build is £822 and the cheapest 8bay synology NAS I can find was over £900 with worse hardware for transcoding etc. I'm starting to plan what i'm going to do. However, in our guide today, we’re going to review Unraid vs. I have a DS220+ (a two drive NAS) with one 8TB drive installed. I have a Synology DS1513+ running for 10 years without much trouble so far connected to a UPS. But not enough to maybe justify the extra setup complexity. Synology. Help So I'm used to having a 3 Looking to do an upgrade, along with adding a new HDD, and so I'm doing the whole 'unraid vs truenas' research thing. But if you want stability without a hassle, use Synology. i want to know why an amd x2 6ghz chip is sitting at 70% total usage when a 1. Unraid does everything that OMV does in terms of docker and portainer. It just allows you to make use of all available storage space of mismatched disk sizes, to an extent. r/unRAID 3 year vs 5 year warranty. For a dependable NAS with important data, Synology is worth it. r/Nikon. For me personally, have I noticed much difference under my uses? Not really. Pros are rated for 300tb/year compared to 180tb/year. Upgrade Recommendations (TrueNAS vs Synology) Question/Advice Currently I have a custom-built box with 4 WD red's and a consumer motherboard running TrueNAS. Unraid vs proxmox on minipc? Already have synology NAS and don't need VM management. But it does make a very effective write cache. I started with FreeNAS through esxi for about 4 years and moved to unraid at 6TB about 4 years ago. It would be $550 for a Synology DS920+, or $300 for DS220+. Unraid is more a energy saving optimized NAS with a little bit docker and vm support. Wont be going back to synology. Unraid is a JBOD solution with parity. Synology vs. But it is just a matter of extra time needed to finish. It works great and it's got ZFS. test folder for If choosing between more parity or less parity + hot spare, always choose more parity. Lots of cold data, some of it important, some less so. So I'm looking into building my first NAS/Plex media server. I ended up moving over to Unraid after I was nearly about to purchase a 4-bay to replace my 2-bay synology. With OpenVPN in a docker on Synology to an external VPN endpoint I was getting 140 Mbps from a *multithreaded cli speedtest, and with Wireguard 177 Mbps. 5Gbit ethernet ports and 6x sata for around 150$ (N100) and 350$ (N305). the only con for container will depend which container since there likely several version and some I have tried windows, ubuntu, unraid 100 percent go unraid going forward stability, scalability . I set up lucky backup to back things up on a schedule, but it's come to my attention that it won't delete things from the destination folder. Which is right for me, UnRAID(HPMS Gen10) vs DSM(Synology DS224+) Hi, I currently have a Synology DS220J, I'm looking to upgrade to either the DS224+ or a HP Micro Server G10. Honestly the main reason for putting the unraid server ahead of the Synology is ease of expansion. At that time, both the Synology and the Unraid were on LAN in the same house. Now, when it comes to 4 vs 5 bays, DS920+ vs DS1520+, I do not know what is better. I knew I wouldn't be happy with the "halfway" solution of something like a Synology, so I stuck it out in the cheap seats until I had the cash and space to put together an Unraid server. I currently have a 16 disk setup with 104tb. It can also be done on UnRAID. Running Unraid Is it possible to replace iCloud for pictures and files with my Synology DS218? This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, r/unRAID. Which brings me to option number two. A Synology is pretty straight forward but for a decent 4 bay like the DS920+ Personally I wouldn't buy hardware to build an unraid box. I know I can add the synology as an unassigned device via SMB but I'd really like to just JBOD the synology and have unraid see it as additional disks as though the synology were a DAS. 0-beta. 5 pb and it works together perfectly. I have used both. One can get decent boards on Aliexpress with 4x 2. I was looking aa the behemoth 12 bay Synology units to reach the storage and horsepower I am a bit spooked by the reviews stating that the ADM interface compared to DSM and the mobile apps are unpolished and outdated compared to the Synology siblings. Or check it out in the app stores From a reliability point I will replace my now 5 year old Synology DS1019+ which worked flawless till now with a follow up model. There's also built in support for all the ARR-based software (Sonarr, Radarr, etc. I ran OMV at work for 2 years and find the UI to be clunky and hacked together compared to unraid. The HP I'm in the process of getting parts together for a Unraid build. - Software is excellent. I've gone through Windows, Linux, Unraid, TrueNAS, Ugreen, Synology, Qnap. I might even consider shifting my unraid to a SFF case to save on footprint. I want to set up my synology nas as remote smb with unraid but I just can't get it to work. I was looking at Synology NAS' etc but they offer kinda rubbish hardware for the price and I'm not overly interested in their first party apps. I am helping my brother-in-law dip his toes into the NAS waters by having him get the DS423+. I've read stuff about the "polish" and such of qnap vs synology. x I find the QNAP interface much more information dense, which I prefer. What caused me to switch is I started running up against issues with Storage Spaces and liked the sound of The biggest difference is that Truenas is a serious operating system, and Synology is a joke/toy. The transcoding wiping out my subtitles wound up driving me to get Bazarr installed and set up, which of course requires sonarr and radarr. That and I would like to put a 10GBE nic in any of the setups. But looking at the current Synology models and the company approach pisses me off a bit. 0->2. Now I hoped my Unraid box would solve all my problems, but it left me wanting. I have now got to grips with the Synology RAID calculator a bit more and have decided to spend the next week or so re-configuring the system. Overkill for the Dockers I run, but I also want to use it to run multiple VMs for dev and tinkering. Unraid has cool easy to run apps though I'm not sure if it has 1-1 parity with all the same apps as Synology I didn't want to burn in maintaining my setup and spend time setting it up. 1 released Synology DS423+ vs QNAP TS-464 NAS Comparison upvote r/Nikon. The only thing that everyone is in agreement on r/synology is that mixing 512/4K drives is not supported I'm building up a new server for it ($800 hardware total and 4x 16TB drives for another $1k) and I am debating between Unraid or TrueNAS. Looking into Unraid (from Synology) but some confusion remains . Finally the RS822+ can be expanded to support a total of 8 drives, where as the RS422+ can only support a View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. So I got digging into unRAID and it seems a good option and allows me to build a cheaper/better DIY NAS. A lot of folks use Unraid and earlier on (don't know right now) there wasn't any support for 12th gen efficiency cores vs performance cores and plex hardware was iffy for brand new igpu. so many apps can't name them all. QNAP - What I said about Synology applies except you need to also not give a shit about security. Not interested in streaming TV, just for photography and videography. fogozv asrn fhxikl gkom ydk vwuo tpb hxhoyzgq mozyym pdl